From: Zulfiqar Halepoto
Date: Apr 3, 2007 11:52 AM
Subject: The Important Issues of Sindh And The Right Approach To Tackle Them(?)
Dear Saeen Rajab and Aziz
Different "thoughts" give different "opinions" on how to proceed further according to their convenience and logic.
For example some nationalist forces are of the view that dialogue I an absurd exercise, Sindh has been talking to every in Pakistan but not a single genuine and legitimate concern is handled by those who controls the power. Federal parties have different strategies. We also have some confused groups, who don't know whether they are pressure groups, revolutionary party, mass moment or what???
Few "orphan" groups rely on the instructions of their abroad-sitting counterparts to work upon.
Here I agree with Saeen Rajab that they submit unrealistic solutions of the problems of Sindh.
One thing is undisputable in the civil society of Sindh to have a dialogue and dialogue and more work on the academic and scientific side of the case of Sindh so that it should be unchallengeable and according to the international standards of presentation and arguments. Water Report of Saeen A N Abbasi and presently Abrar Kazi's document for FORD FOUNDATION on the "Non-Traditional Threats to Water security Paradigms in Pakistan" are the best example of it.
I think here we agree with Saeen Rajab and Aziz to develop an all-inclusive strategy to proceed further, a strategy without rhetoric and unrealistic slogans. May be some times we get engaged with any body as proposed by the contributors here in this debate.
May be few political groups do not subscribe this idea and here is the role of intelligentsia is required to draw a way out.
Regards
Zulfi
"Dr. Rajab Ali Memon" wrote:
Dear Aziz and the Group:
Date: Apr 3, 2007 11:52 AM
Subject: The Important Issues of Sindh And The Right Approach To Tackle Them(?)
Dear Saeen Rajab and Aziz
Different "thoughts" give different "opinions" on how to proceed further according to their convenience and logic.
For example some nationalist forces are of the view that dialogue I an absurd exercise, Sindh has been talking to every in Pakistan but not a single genuine and legitimate concern is handled by those who controls the power. Federal parties have different strategies. We also have some confused groups, who don't know whether they are pressure groups, revolutionary party, mass moment or what???
Few "orphan" groups rely on the instructions of their abroad-sitting counterparts to work upon.
Here I agree with Saeen Rajab that they submit unrealistic solutions of the problems of Sindh.
One thing is undisputable in the civil society of Sindh to have a dialogue and dialogue and more work on the academic and scientific side of the case of Sindh so that it should be unchallengeable and according to the international standards of presentation and arguments. Water Report of Saeen A N Abbasi and presently Abrar Kazi's document for FORD FOUNDATION on the "Non-Traditional Threats to Water security Paradigms in Pakistan" are the best example of it.
I think here we agree with Saeen Rajab and Aziz to develop an all-inclusive strategy to proceed further, a strategy without rhetoric and unrealistic slogans. May be some times we get engaged with any body as proposed by the contributors here in this debate.
May be few political groups do not subscribe this idea and here is the role of intelligentsia is required to draw a way out.
Regards
Zulfi
"Dr. Rajab Ali Memon" wrote:
Dear Aziz and the Group:
I wholeheartedly support the views of Mr. Aziz Narejo who has given wonderful leadership to the SANA during the last one year or so. There are still some friends, specially some permanently residing abroad, who tend to give radical and unrealistic solutions to the issues facing us. Anything different is considered as being a traitor to Sindh. I believe these arguments plus research-based educated input on various issues can help entering into dialogue with other nations forming the state of Pakistan. Recent events indicate that such a multi-disciplinary dialogue may soon become the need of everyone in Pakistan, including the Punjab bureaucracy and establishment, etc., if they are patriotic in the true sense. Thanks.
Dr. Rajab Ali Memon
HEC Merit Professor in Social Sciences
________________________________
0 comments:
Post a Comment